Are the viral photos and videos from Europe's youth protests real?

Are the viral photos and videos from Europe's youth protests real?

核查于 · 更新于 · 已复查 · 持续关注至

谣言: After mass protests in France, Germany and the Netherlands, social media filled with a "burning Eiffel Tower", a "looted street where only a workwear shop survived", "ads selling a single shoe", a "robbed elderly couple in Paris" and a letter promising "€50 for joining a demonstration".

1. 结论

虚假

The most viral images of this wave are fakes: made by AI, edited from old photos, or taken from a clip more than a year old. The letter about "€50 per protester" is invented; the agency that supposedly sent it does not exist. The protests themselves are real: on 17 October in France and 31 October in Germany there were both peaceful marches and looting of shops, but on a smaller scale and not where the fakes claim.

High: each fake was debunked independently by different fact-checkers (Correctiv, AFP, dpa, Full Fact, France 24, Annie Lab), and Germany's Interior Ministry and the letter's own author confirmed the forgery. Not "very high": we saw the statements of the ministry and the Kleinanzeigen platform only as reported by fact-checkers and did not rerun the AI checks ourselves.

2. 更新

  • . The wave continues, and we have added new fakes. On 6 November Mimikama showed that a video of a huge column of fire "in Berlin" was filmed at an Easter bonfire in Limassol, Cyprus, in 2024. On 7 November Fact Crescendo debunked a clip of "French looters selling iPhones and Rolexes on the streets of Paris": it was filmed in Madrid and posted back on 12 October. We also added late-October fact checks missing from the first version: a photo of a "shop with a Putin portrait left untouched in Paris" (AI-edited from a 2018 photo), an attacker's face in Nice swapped by AI, and old videos from Poland, Portugal and Argentina passed off as the current protests. The verdict is unchanged.[15][16][17][18][19]
  • . We added two new fact checks. On 8 November Provereno looked at a video of masked people failing to smash a shop window in Paris. It is being passed off as an ad for the Chinese glass maker Hengxinfeng, whose orders supposedly "shot up". The video was filmed in Paris, at the Forum des Halles shopping centre, but there is no evidence the company turned it into an ad; in Russian-language Telegram such posts got more than 4 million views. On 6 November Correctiv showed that a "kindergarten notice cancelling the St. Martin's Day procession out of respect for other cultures" was made by AI. It is not about the protests, but it is part of the same wave of AI fakes in Germany. The verdict is unchanged.[20][21]
  • . We added a second independent fact check of the burning Eiffel Tower video, by Lead Stories (published on 21 October; we had not included it before). According to it, the clip appeared on X as early as 18 October, the day after the looting, with a caption about "peaceful students" who "burned down the Eiffel Tower". The Hive and Sightengine detectors rated it 85.6% and 99% likely AI; the building in front of the tower has windows of different shapes, and some windows disappear. Webcams showed the tower intact, and the official website said it was open. The verdict is unchanged.[4]

3. 说法与事实

  • «A photo shows a Berlin street after the 31 October riots: every shop smashed, only a workwear shop left intact»虚假

    The image was made by AI. Google's SynthID detector identified all three versions (with German, French and Dutch captions) as created with an OpenAI tool. The lettering on the signs is distorted and the glass in every window is broken in the same way. The picture includes an ICI Paris XL store, a chain with no branches in Germany. The image had circulated for weeks before the protests, often as a joke.[1]

  • «Video: the Eiffel Tower burns during protests in Paris»虚假

    The video and audio were made with Google AI, as SynthID showed, and the Hive detector rated it 99% likely AI. The same clip was posted back in September 2025. Objects thrown at the tower vanish at the 4-second mark. A webcam showed the tower intact at the time, and no closure was announced. Lead Stories independently reached the same conclusion: the Hive and Sightengine detectors gave an 85.6% and 99% likelihood of AI, and the building in front of the tower has windows of different shapes, some of which disappear.[3][4]

  • «After the looting in Frankfurt, the classifieds site Kleinanzeigen is flooded with ads selling single shoes from looted shop windows»虚假

    Kleinanzeigen told Correctiv that no such ads existed. One similar ad is known, but it was posted in early October, before the unrest, from another region, and later altered by a third party. Some screenshots carry an eBay logo the platform has not used since 2023. One TikTok video is labelled as AI-generated. Only one detail is true: the Snipes chain confirmed that many single left shoes were stolen from its windows.[2]

  • «A German federal agency pays €50 to everyone who joins the 31 October demonstration»虚假

    The letter is forged. The "Federal Office for Social Cohesion and Democracy Promotion" is not in the register of federal authorities, and its website does not work. The address and phone number in the letter belong to Germany's Interior Ministry. A ministry spokesperson told AFP on 27 October that it does not know of such an agency. The letter's author admitted to AFP that he made it with ChatGPT.[5][6][7]

  • «Photo: during the riots in Paris an elderly couple was stripped and robbed»虚假

    Both images were made with OpenAI tools, as SynthID showed. They show a hand with four fingers, two heads on one body, and a street bollard that is not a Paris design. The Paris prosecutor's office said it had received no reports of such an attack.[10][8]

  • «Paris shops hung hams outside their doors to deter looters»虚假

    The photos were altered with AI. The originals were found on a travel blog from 2024 and January 2026, and the shop fronts there have no hams. The shop sign reflects no ham, even though one hangs right in front of it.[11]

  • «Photo: in Paris every shop was smashed except a Russian souvenir shop with a Putin portrait»虚假

    The image was built from an old photo of a smashed Starbucks café in Paris during the 2018 "yellow vest" protests, with AI-added details. There is no Russian shop at the address shown. A passer-by's face is out of proportion, and the matryoshka doll and the portrait look warped. "Every shop" is also untrue: Paris City Hall counted 450 damaged commercial premises on 17–18 October. The fake was pushed by Russian propaganda outlets and Telegram channels.[17]

  • «Photo: during the riots in France a man jumps and kicks another man in the back»歪曲

    The attack really happened — in Nice, outside the Micromania video game shop. But the viral image was altered with AI: Google and OpenAI checking tools found an OpenAI watermark in it. In the original video the attacker wears a balaclava; in the image he has a hood, a moustache and curly hair.[18]

  • «Videos: millions joined protests in Europe; Portugal sent the army against protesters; Italians tear down a US flag»虚假

    All three clips are old or from elsewhere. The "millions" are Poland's annual Independence Day march, a video circulating since 2017 (over 1 million views on X). The "army" is preparation for Army Day in Porto; protests in Portugal are handled by police, not the army. The flag was torn down in Buenos Aires, Argentina, in August.[19]

  • «Video: a huge fire is burning in Berlin after the protests»虚假

    It is an Easter bonfire in Limassol, Cyprus, posted on TikTok on 5 May 2024. The buildings match street-view imagery. The clip was posted on X on 1 November and was also used by Herbert Kickl, leader of Austria's far-right FPÖ party.[15]

  • «Video: French protesters sell looted iPhones, Rolexes and Louis Vuitton on the streets of Paris»虚假

    The video was filmed on Gran Vía in Madrid: a bus marked "Madrid" and a metro sign are visible. The earliest copy was posted on 12 October, before the 17 October looting in France. The original captions say nothing about looting.[16]

  • «Chinese glass maker Hengxinfeng turned a video of French rioters failing to smash its shop window into an ad, and its orders shot up»虚假

    The video is real and was filmed in Paris: masked people try to smash a window, apparently of an Adidas store, at the Forum des Halles shopping centre. But when it was filmed is unknown. The earliest version found appeared on 25 October, a week after the riots, with no Chinese captions. Hengxinfeng was linked to the clip only on 27 October, on Telegram. The company has no official social media and its website does not work. An Instagram account with its name was created in March 2026, and the caption does not say the glass is theirs. Provereno found no confirmation of an ad or of rising orders.[20]

  • «Protests and looting really did happen in Europe»属实

    Yes. In France, school and university students have been protesting poor learning conditions since late September. On 17 October trade unions joined with protests against the rising cost of living; estimates put turnout at 550,000 to 800,000, and shops were looted in Paris and other cities. In Germany, rallies took place in more than 30 cities on 31 October. Most participants were peaceful, but in Frankfurt 17 shops were damaged, 5 looted and 54 people arrested. In The Hague on 31 October, shops boarded up their windows in advance and police detained young people, even though no demonstration had been registered.[13][8][12][14]

4. 谣言从哪里来

  • ≈ Facebook

    The same "burning Eiffel Tower" clip is already posted on Facebook, more than a year before the protests.[3]

  • France, city streets · fr

    Nationwide day of protest against the cost of living. Shops are looted in Paris, Lyon, Marseille and other cities.[13]

  • X, Instagram · Infos-Israel.news · fr

    A montage with AI photos of a "stripped and robbed elderly couple" appears. Large accounts amplify it, and views run into the millions.[10]

  • X · en

    A clip of the "burning Eiffel Tower" is posted on X with the caption "peaceful students burned down the Eiffel Tower".[4]

  • France 24 · en

    France 24 shows the couple photos were made by AI; the Paris prosecutor's office says there are no reports of an attack.[10]

  • Facebook · en

    A Nigeria-based account (about 7,500 followers) posts the "burning Eiffel Tower" clip as footage of the protests.[3]

  • X, Threads, Instagram · ko

    A Korean X post with "hams outside Paris shops" gets more than 9,900 likes; the images spread to Threads and Instagram in Korean and Chinese.[11]

  • Full Fact · en

    Full Fact publishes a roundup of fact checks on the French protests: AI clips with fireworks at the Eiffel Tower, the "Pink Panther", old police footage.[8]

  • Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, X · de

    The letter about "€50 for joining a demonstration" (dated 22 October) is posted. The Facebook post is shared more than 1,500 times.[5]

  • dpa, German Interior Ministry · de

    dpa calls the letter a forgery; the Interior Ministry tells AFP it does not know of such an agency. The next day the author admits to AFP that he made the letter himself.[6][5]

  • Germany, Netherlands · de

    Youth rallies in Germany (organisers estimate 100,000–120,000 participants) and in The Hague. Unrest in Frankfurt, Cologne, Nuremberg and parts of Berlin.[12][14]

  • TikTok, Instagram, Facebook · de

    The AI image with the "surviving workwear shop" is passed off as Berlin after 31 October; the same day, "ads selling a single shoe" spread.[1][2]

  • Correctiv · de

    Correctiv debunks the "single shoe ads", citing Kleinanzeigen.[2]

  • Correctiv, AFP, Annie Lab

    Debunks of the "Berlin" image, the Eiffel Tower video and the ham photos.[1][3][11]

  • Mimikama · de

    Mimikama: the "Berlin fire" video was filmed at an Easter bonfire in Cyprus in 2024.[15]

  • Fact Crescendo · ml

    The "looted goods on sale in Paris" clip reaches India; Fact Crescendo shows it was filmed in Madrid.[16]

  • Provereno · ru

    Provereno: the "unbreakable shop window" video was filmed in Paris, but it was never an ad for the Chinese company Hengxinfeng. Earlier, between 25 and 28 October, the clip travelled from X and Weibo to Russian-language Telegram, where the company name and "rising orders" were added.[20]

文本如何变化

  1. Workwear shop image: first a meme with no location; the earliest version found is on a French-language Threads account
  2. → Then versions appeared with German and Dutch captions above the shop
  3. → 1 November: + "this is Berlin after the 31 October protests"
  4. → Eiffel Tower: a September 2025 clip + the caption "history unravelling in real time" during the October 2026 protests
  5. → "Paid to protest": an old myth, possibly from a 2015 satirical piece in taz, + a "federal agency" letter made with ChatGPT, + a specific amount and the 31 October date
  6. → Robbed couple: first a BFM journalist's words citing police, then + AI photos, then + "the couple is Jewish" and accusations against Muslims and the government
  7. → "Unbreakable shop window": 25 October — just a video from Paris; 26 October — + Chinese captions and "glass from Henan province"; 27 October — + the company name Hengxinfeng and "a sharp rise in orders"

5. 媒体怎么说

  • Correctiv (Germany)辟谣

    The "looted Berlin" image was made by AI; there were no "single shoe ads" on Kleinanzeigen.[1][2]

  • AFP辟谣

    The burning Eiffel Tower video was made by AI and posted as early as 2025; the "protest money" letter is forged, and its author admitted it.[3][5]

  • Lead Stories (US)辟谣

    The burning Eiffel Tower video was made by AI, as detectors and flaws in the image show; webcams showed the tower intact.[4]

  • dpa, Mimikama辟谣

    The agency in the €50 letter does not exist; the address and phone number were taken from the Interior Ministry.[6][7]

  • Full Fact, France 24辟谣

    A series of AI fakes about the French protests: the elderly couple, fireworks at the Eiffel Tower, the "Pink Panther", old police footage.[8][10][9]

  • Annie Lab (Hong Kong)辟谣

    The photos of Paris shops with hams are real pictures with the hams added by AI.[11]

  • Mimikama, Fact Crescendo辟谣

    The "Berlin fire" is a 2024 Easter bonfire in Cyprus; the "looted goods on sale in Paris" video was filmed in Madrid.[15][16]

  • France 24, Correctiv, Ukrinform辟谣

    Old videos from Poland, Portugal and Argentina passed off as the protests; the attacker's face in Nice swapped by AI; the "Putin portrait shop" AI-edited.[19][18][17]

  • Provereno辟谣

    The video of an attempt to smash a shop window in Paris was not an ad for a Chinese glass maker; there is no evidence of "rising orders".[20]

  • The Local, France 24, TPO背景

    What actually happened at the protests: scale, cities, arrests, and where shops were actually looted.[12][13][14]

6. 社交媒体

  • TikTok, Facebook, Instagram恐慌

    The "surviving workwear shop" image is passed off as Berlin, France or the Netherlands. Some posts carry an AI label.[1]

    2026-11-01 · hundreds of thousands of TikTok views (per Correctiv, 2026-11-04)

  • X恐慌

    Large accounts amplify the AI photo of the "robbed elderly couple"; Alex Jones shared one of the images.[10]

    2026-10-17 · millions of views (per France 24, 2026-10-19)

  • X中性

    A Korean post with "hams outside Paris shops". In the comments, the images are used against Muslims.[11]

    2026-10-22 · more than 9,900 likes and 2,800 reposts (per Annie Lab, 2026-11-04)

  • Facebook中性

    The letter about "€50 per demonstrator". Its author later told AFP he wanted to annoy the far right.[5]

    2026-10-23 · more than 1,500 shares (per AFP, 2026-10-30)

  • TikTok, Instagram · Julius Böhm (Nius writer)讽刺

    A video about "single shoe ads". The author called it satire, but it carried no satire label.[2]

    2026-11-01

  • Telegram, X, VKontakte · Alexander Nevzorov讽刺

    The "unbreakable shop window" video is presented as a clever ad for Chinese glass set against the French riots.[20]

    2026-10-28 · 345,000 views on Nevzorov's post; more than 500 posts and 4 million views on Telegram overall (per Provereno, 2026-11-08)

7. 操纵迹象

  • Tied to a real event. Looting did happen in Frankfurt and Paris, so the invented images look plausible.
  • Old material passed off as new. The Eiffel Tower clip was posted in September 2025; the workwear shop image circulated for weeks before 31 October.
  • One image, different countries. The same "looted row of shops" is captioned as Berlin, France or the Netherlands.
  • Forged official document. A non-existent "federal agency", the Interior Ministry's address and phone number, and an amount "reduced due to budget cuts".
  • Playing on fear and anger at entire groups. The "robbed couple" photo ran under the headline "Islam Conquers Europe"; the ham images were discussed in the same vein.
  • "It's satire" — after it spread. The author of the shoe video called it satire, but the video had no label.

8. 过去的类似谣言

  • Photo: protesters among bodies at the Eiffel Tower during the riots in France

    结果: The image was made by AI: one person has three legs, and detectors flagged it as AI.[22]

  • Photo: Macron sitting in the street in front of burning rubbish during the riots

    结果: Full Fact: the image was made by AI.[23]

  • Photo: British police kneeling before Muslim men (after the Southport riots)

    结果: Lead Stories: the image was made by AI and first posted with the caption "How AI sees London".[24]

与过去谣言的共同点

  • Real unrest serves as the backdrop, while the most striking images are invented
  • A recognisable city landmark on fire (the Eiffel Tower, just as in 2023)
  • The images are used to blame entire groups of people

新内容

  • One AI image appears in versions in three languages at once and "moves" from country to country
  • Fakes are caught by an invisible AI watermark (SynthID), not just by extra fingers
  • The forged "official document" is also AI-made and uses the ministry's real address and phone number
  • The fakes reach beyond the street into everyday life: classified ads, shop windows

10. 应该怎么做

  • If an image looks too "perfect" (everything smashed, one funny spot left intact), run a reverse image search — it often predates the event itself.
  • Look at the details: lettering on signs, hands, identical cracks. AI often gets them wrong.
  • Check letters about "payments for taking part" on the named agency's website and in the official register of public bodies; if the agency doesn't exist, it's a forgery.
  • Don't forward an image that makes you angry at an entire group of people until local media or fact-checkers have confirmed it.

11. 我们未能核实的内容

  • Who first made the workwear shop image is unknown: the earliest post found is on a French-language Threads account that did not respond to Correctiv.
  • We did not rerun the AI checks (SynthID, Hive) ourselves — we rely on the results of Correctiv, AFP, France 24 and Annie Lab.
  • The statements of Germany's Interior Ministry and of Kleinanzeigen are known only as reported by AFP and Correctiv.
  • Neither AFP nor Lead Stories says how many people watched the Eiffel Tower video.
  • We found no separate fact checks of AI fakes from this wave for Italy or other countries.
  • The attack on the elderly couple, first mentioned by a BFM journalist, has been neither confirmed nor conclusively disproved — only the photos are proven fake.
  • Only Ukrinform has debunked the "Putin shop" image; the other fact-checkers we found did not check it. Its reach is unknown.
  • NewsGuard reports a Russian campaign with dozens of invented "news stories" about the protests, but we could not access the article — details are unverified.
  • Provereno could not confirm that the "unbreakable shop window" video was filmed during the 17–18 October riots; who first attributed it to Hengxinfeng is also unknown.

12. 来源

  1. Correctiv — "Berlin riot" image made by AI (4 November 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.06
  2. Correctiv — there were no "single shoe ads" (3 November 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.06
  3. AFP (Yahoo News UK) — burning Eiffel Tower video made by AI · 访问于 2026.11.06
  4. Lead Stories (Yahoo News) — the Eiffel Tower did not burn during the protests, the video is AI-made (21 October 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.09
  5. AFP / GADMO — "protest money" letter is forged (30 October 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.06
  6. dpa — invented agency and forged document · 访问于 2026.11.06
  7. Mimikama — letter about €50 for the 31 October demonstration · 访问于 2026.11.06
  8. Full Fact — fact checks on the French protests (22 October 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.06
  9. Full Fact — "Pink Panther" at the protests made by AI · 访问于 2026.11.06
  10. France 24 — AI photos of a "robbed elderly couple" · 访问于 2026.11.06
  11. Annie Lab — hams outside Paris shops added by AI · 访问于 2026.11.06
  12. The Local — what really happened at Germany's protests · 访问于 2026.11.06
  13. France 24 — shop looting in French cities on 17 October · 访问于 2026.11.06
  14. TPO — The Hague on 31 October: arrests, boarded-up shop windows · 访问于 2026.11.06
  15. Mimikama — the "Berlin fire" is actually an Easter bonfire in Cyprus (6 November 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.08
  16. Fact Crescendo — "looted goods on sale in Paris" video was filmed in Madrid (7 November 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.08
  17. Ukrinform — fake about a shop with a Putin portrait left untouched in Paris (22 October 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.08
  18. Correctiv — image of the Nice attack altered with AI (23 October 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.08
  19. France 24 — old videos from Poland, Portugal and Argentina passed off as protests in Europe (26 October 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.08
  20. Provereno — video from the French protests was not an ad for Chinese glass (8 November 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.09
  21. Correctiv — notice cancelling a St. Martin's procession was made by AI (6 November 2026) · 访问于 2026.11.09
  22. BOOM — AI photo at the Eiffel Tower during the 2023 riots · 访问于 2026.11.06
  23. Full Fact — AI photo of Macron by burning rubbish (2023) · 访问于 2026.11.06
  24. Lead Stories — AI photo of British police kneeling (2024) · 访问于 2026.11.06

#protests#Europe#France#Germany#Netherlands#AI images#forged documents#deepfakes

最新消息